Best Developmental Editors for Fiction

You’ve done it. You've reached 'The End,' and completed the first draft of your novel. That alone is a monumental achievement, but the journey isn’t over. As authors, we're too close to our own stories to see the whole picture. The first draft is for you, but the revision is for your reader. Things inevitably change during the writing process. Maybe you're writing a romance and realized halfway through that a side character had far better chemistry with your protagonist. Perhaps you're crafting an epic fantasy and a brilliant piece of worldbuilding occurred to you in chapter ten, which now changes everything that came before.

This is where developmental editing comes in. It’s the transformative stage of revision, focusing on the big-picture elements of the story. In this article, we'll show you how to find the best developmental editor for your novel, so you can turn that draft into a story that shines.

What Does a Developmental Editor Do?

A developmental editor is your manuscript's architect and structural engineer rolled into one. Unlike copyeditors who polish prose and grammar, developmental editors examine the foundational elements of your story. They evaluate plot structure, character development, pacing, narrative arc, and overall coherence. This is the stage you might combine two characters into one, cut or move chapters around, change who your ultimate villain is, or rework the setting and time period.

If you need a refresher on what kind of story feedback you need at different phases of your writing journey, check out our helpful guide.

Professional developmental editing services typically provide a comprehensive editorial letter and in-depth manuscript feedback on:

• Plot and story structure: Identifying plot holes, pacing issues, and structural weaknesses.
• Character development: Ensuring characters are compelling, consistent, and have clear motivations.
• Point of view and voice: Maintaining consistency and effectiveness in the narrative perspective.
• World-building and setting: Helping to create believable, immersive environments.
• Theme and message: Ensuring your story's deeper meaning comes through clearly.
• Genre conventions: Making sure your book meets reader expectations for its category.

A skilled developmental editor provides detailed manuscript feedback that goes beyond surface-level corrections, offering actionable suggestions for revisions that can transform a good story into a great one.

Preparing Your Manuscript for a Developmental Editor

To get the most value from a developmental edit, it's essential to prepare your manuscript properly.

First, ensure your draft is complete. A developmental editor needs the entire story to analyze its overarching structure and character arcs. After finishing, let the manuscript rest for a few weeks. This distance will give you a fresh perspective for one last read-through to catch any obvious issues yourself.

Before sending it off, format your manuscript for easy reading using a standard font, double spacing, and page numbers. It’s also helpful to prepare a brief summary of your story, along with a list of main characters and a clear identification of your genre and target audience.

Top Places to Find Developmental Editors

Professional Editorial Organizations

Professional organizations are a reliable starting point for finding qualified editors. They often have searchable directories and require members to meet certain professional standards.

• The Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA) maintains a comprehensive directory of experienced editors, including those specializing in fiction developmental editing.
• The Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP), the UK's professional body for editors and proofreaders, offers a similar directory of vetted professionals.
• Editors Canada also provides a directory of editors with various specializations and experience levels.

Online Marketplaces and Curated Platforms

Online platforms offer a convenient way to connect with a wide range of freelance editors.

• Reedsy has become a leading platform for connecting authors with high-quality, vetted professionals. You can browse detailed profiles, read client reviews, and request quotes from multiple editors.
• The Book Designer and Writer's Digest also feature curated lists and marketplaces for finding professional editors who specialize in various fiction genres.

Referrals and Writing Communities

Word-of-mouth recommendations are invaluable. Engage with other writers in online communities like AbsoluteWrite and QueryTracker, or in genre-specific writing groups. Authors are often happy to share their positive experiences and recommend editors who were instrumental in their success.

How Much Does Developmental Editing Cost?

Investing in a developmental edit is a significant financial decision. Rates can vary widely based on the editor's experience, the manuscript's length, and the complexity of the genre. Most editors charge per word, with typical rates for developmental editing ranging from $0.03 to $0.05 per word. For a novel of 80,000 words, a developmental edit can range from approximately $2,400 to $4,000 or more. Always request a quote and clarify what is included in the fee before committing.

AI Tools For Developmental Editing

While human editors provide irreplaceable nuance and creative insight, technology offers new tools for authors. AI-powered software can provide a valuable first pass on big-picture story elements, a practice known as AI developmental editing.

Platforms like Inkshift are designed to help authors analyze their own work. These tools generate detailed reports on story structure, pacing, character arcs, and the balance of dialogue versus narrative. They work by analyzing your story's structure, flagging potential plot holes, and evaluating scenes against dozens of key story elements.

These AI tools are not a replacement for a professional human editor, a fact the platforms themselves acknowledge. However, they are affordable and fast, making them an excellent option for authors on a tight budget or those who want to self-edit as thoroughly as possible before hiring a professional. Inkshift's full manuscript analysis is just $25 and includes sample query letters, a synopsis, comparable titles, and a marketability assessment.

If you'd like to learn more about Inkshift, you'll find an overview here.

Essential Questions to Ask Before Hiring an Editor

To find the right partner for your manuscript, it's crucial to ask thoughtful questions.

Experience and Specialization

• "What genres do you specialize in, and can you share your experience with [your specific genre]?"
• "Could you provide references or testimonials from past fiction clients?"
• "What do you enjoy most about developmental editing?"

Process and Deliverables

• "Could I see a sample of your developmental feedback on a few pages of my manuscript?"
• "What does your typical developmental editing package include? (e.g., editorial letter, in-line comments)"
• "What is your philosophy on maintaining the author's voice?"

Timeline and Communication

• "What is your estimated turnaround time for a manuscript of my length?"
• "How much follow-up communication is included in your fee?"
• "Are you available for a call to discuss the feedback?"

Conclusion

Developmental editing is a key part of any novel's journey from rough draft to bookshelf, and finding the right one can help shave months or years off your writing time. It’s an investment in your story’s potential and your growth as a writer. Whether you choose to work with a seasoned professional from a reputable organization, find a hidden gem through a writing community, or use AI developmental editing to refine your drafts, the goal is the same: get the building blocks in place so you can focus on prose and copyediting. By taking a thoughtful approach, preparing your manuscript, and asking the right questions, you can find an editorial partner who will help you unlock the powerful, compelling story waiting within your draft.